Good Fellas Tavern Argyle
Good Fellas Tavern Logo

Good Fellas Tavern

@

4.8850 reviews

Good Fellas Tavern offers a blend of classic tavern vibes and restaurant-quality food. Located on S State St in Argyle, it stands out for its excellent cocktails and friendly service. This tavern welcomes both locals and visitors with open arms, promising an unforgettable dining experience. Whether you're stopping by for lunch or dinner, the menu packs flavor and quality into every dish. Affordable prices complement fantastic food, ensuring every guest leaves satisfied. Open late, it creates the perfect spot for late-night cravings. Good Fellas mixes great drinks with a warm atmosphere, making it a must-visit spot in town.

About

Good Fellas Tavern has established itself as a local gem in Argyle. The tavern radiates a casual and friendly vibe, ideal for groups and families alike. Inside, the decor reflects a cozy atmosphere that warmly welcomes visitors. Patrons rave about the attentive service; staff treats customers like family. Located conveniently on S State St, it's accessible for everyone, including those needing wheelchair access. The tavern generates a strong sense of community, hosting local concerts and sports events, where the energy is vibrant. This space thrives on bringing people together, making Good Fellas a cornerstone of Argyle's dining scene.

Get in Touch

109 S State St, Argyle, WI 53504, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday 10:30-02:00
  • Tuesday Closed
  • Wednesday Closed
  • Thursday 10:30-02:00
  • Friday 10:30-02:30
  • Saturday 10:30-02:30
  • Sunday 10:30-02:00

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"We stopped into Good Fellas Pub on our way home from a wrestling tournament with two very hungry kids. Even though it was just before the kitchen was closing, Hailey gladly took our order and made us feel so welcome. Once we arrived, she gave us the best service--we truly appreciated her kindness and attentiveness. The pizza was absolutely delicious and hit the spot after a long day. We're so glad we found this place and will definitely be returning. Highly recommend"

- Haley A.

"Unbelievable service from start to finish! You know customer service is a priority from the awesome food, drinks, and atmosphere they provide. If you are ever near Argyle, Good Fellas will never disappoint!"

- Lance R.

"Great food. Good atmosphere. Friendly staff. Had a burger, dill pickle cheese curds and the cheese fries, called "cheese sticks." This was our second time here and it hasn't disappointed."

- Dan P.

"Friendly small town atmosphere, attentive service, good selection, and good food. Will definitely be back!"

- Angela A.

"Great food in a friendly atmosphere. Always fun to visit. I enjoy a few unique menu items."

- Mike Z.

"What an awesome neighborhood bar! One of the best burgers I've had. The fried string-beans and half-nekkid curds are to die for. Seriously, their food is so yummy, we ate there twice when we were only in town for a few days. Friendly folks, great food!"

- Anna W.

"Stopped in for Pizza of the Month which was White Garlic Meatball. The pizza was pretty good. Like garlic bread with pizza on it. The crust was much thinner then I expected. Overall a good experience but I hoped for a more filling pizza."

- David
Write a Review

Why Visit

Visiting Good Fellas Tavern means enjoying hearty meals in a laid-back atmosphere. The menu features delicious options like burgers, pizzas, and cheese curds, sure to please all appetites. Make sure to try the 'Big Fella' burger or their unique Chicken Fajita Pizza, which combines traditional flavors in bold ways. For those who love trying local specialties, Good Fellas highlights regional dishes, showcasing the best of local cuisine. Happy hour deals on food and drinks occur regularly, making it a great spot for groups to gather. Plan visits around peak hours for lively sports events, but quieter times offer a chance to enjoy a relaxing meal. With accessible parking and a friendly atmosphere, the tavern welcomes all.

Most Liked things

Patrons love the excellent variety of beers and cocktails available. The inviting atmosphere provides a great backdrop for social gatherings. Customers frequently mention friendly staff and responsive service. Highlight dishes include the delicious pizza and inviting 'Big Fella' burger. Live events and local concerts create fun experiences worth sharing. Many appreciate the quick service and great prices, making it accessible for families and individuals alike. Good Fellas truly shines in creating a community hub through excellent food and engaging events.

Most Disliked things

Some guests experience longer wait times during peak hours, particularly on busy Saturdays. A few patrons mention limited healthy options on the menu, which could be expanded. The space can feel crowded at times, especially during popular events or games. A few diners note that late-night crowds can be louder than expected. Limited hours on certain weekdays may restrict access for some visitors. However, the overall experience often outweighs these minor inconveniences, as service remains attentive and the food consistently delights.

FAQ

What drinks can be found at Good Fellas Tavern?

Good Fellas Tavern offers a vast selection of drinks. The cocktail menu features excellent choices. Local beers are available and there's a happy hour to enjoy discounts on drinks.

Is Good Fellas Tavern suitable for large groups?

Yes, Good Fellas Tavern is perfect for large groups. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming. It accommodates tourists and locals alike.

What’s the price range for meals at Good Fellas Tavern?

The prices at Good Fellas Tavern range from $10 to $20. Many dishes, including burgers and salads, fit within this budget. You can enjoy quality food without breaking the bank.

Are there vegetarian options available?

Yes, Good Fellas Tavern provides several vegetarian options. Choices include salads and sides like cheese curds. There are also grilled chicken strips for those seeking lighter fare.